Welcome To Buttercup’s Oven!


All my products are made with only fresh ingredients, no preservatives and the perfect amount of love!

A taste of home, remember those cold winter days when you snuggle into a warm blanket and listen to the soft sounds of winter? Along with those memories are delectable smells of baked goods easing their way into the whole house. Those days remind us of home and are experiences we love to share with our customers. Buttercup’s Oven might not be able to control the weather, but we can provide you with the decadent tastes of home baked goods.





Protein Muffins

What We Do


Fresh Ingredients

Just like what you’d find in grandma’s baking, we only use local ingredients and no preservatives.

Straight Out Of The Oven

To ensure you receive the freshest goods to your doorstep, all items are made to order and shipped within hours of baking.

Made To Order

Although we don’t have a brick & mortar location, Buttercup’s Oven can be enjoyed nationwide in any state!


We create unique and delicious favors for all kinds of events. Our edible favors will be gifts your guests actually enjoy parting with.

Pure Skills

After years of baking with my grandma and mother, my passion for baking has developed into a career. Grandma’s traditional methods have been passed onto me, and now I’m developing them into something a bit more modern, yet keeping that rustic edge.

Well Mixed

Although we want to showcase our traditional recipes, we’re constantly evolving the presentation of these recipes creating unique spins on tried and true delicacies.

What Others Say About Us

At Buttercup’s Oven we strive to keep our 5 Star Reviews

The crumb cakes, the minis that I received, were packaged beautifully and they were the tastiest crumb cakes ever! I will surely order them again and recommend them to anyone.Plus Alexandra is a delight to deal with. I recommend them to anyone


I bought these as a gift and the recipient loved them. This was my first time buying edible gifts and it was a real pleasure buying from this seller. Great communication, fast shipping, and a delicious product from what I hear.


In my 70+ years I’ve eaten Almond crescents in Germany, Switzerland, Austria and the USA. These delicious cookies surpass them all in taste and texture. Mobility issues prevent baking myself; now I have the perfect solution. Not inexpensive but worth every penny for an authentic European experience. Recommend highly!


I just had to tell you I just received the donuts! They are the bomb!! I am a baker myself but didn’t have the time right now to make donuts & I need them to make a bread pudding for a family event. I can’t remember the last time I was so impressed by something someone else baked. I don’t want to sound like a snob or anything but baking is my therapy & has been for years so I find I am hard to impress. But you did impress!! Love them & will probably be sending you another order soon so we have some just to eat! Awesome!! Thank you!!


About Us

Buttercup’s Oven remembers “A Taste of Home” and bakes that in every batch.

I always loved it when grandma would come down the stairs from her apartment with her wonderful baked goods. As she opened up the door to our section of the house, her arms were always filled with the goodies she just baked that morning. The air would change in our house and a warmth of spices would creep in with her as she shuffled through the door. She was such a great baker; everything that came out of her oven was never short from spectacular. I had the privileged to learn from her and my mother for most of my life. Although, I haven’t had formal training in the art of baking, I have been in the thick of it since I could walk. Developing my own recipes and evolving ones that have been passed on have been apart of me since I can remember, and now I have the privileged to share that with you. I hope you enjoy this journey as much as I do.

Our Gallery

We value your feedback and would love you to follow us on our instagram page.

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Error: No posts found.

Make sure this account has posts available on instagram.com.

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

Error: No posts found.

Make sure this account has posts available on instagram.com.

  • Crumb Cake in a Jar
  • Grandma’s Famous Crumb Cake
  • Peanut Butter Heavens
  • Old World Almond Crescents
  • Apple Cider Donuts
  • Down & Dirties
  • Salted Caramel Bliss Bars & Cups
  • Rustic Rye Bread
  • Pignoli Cookies
  • Browned Butter Churro Donuts

Upcoming Events

Dates will be listed soon...

Follow Us

Visit Us

Matawan, New Jersey